TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
OK - I may have finally found the culprit.
I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
It isn't 1 mm at the edge of the tire.... remember the calculations for
leverage from physics class and since the wheel is rotating we have to factor in constantly changing vectors of acceleration..... "Justin M" <xtexatl@gmail.com> wrote in message news:1163276739.067460.155360@h54g2000cwb.googlegr oups.com... > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? > |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
It isn't 1 mm at the edge of the tire.... remember the calculations for
leverage from physics class and since the wheel is rotating we have to factor in constantly changing vectors of acceleration..... "Justin M" <xtexatl@gmail.com> wrote in message news:1163276739.067460.155360@h54g2000cwb.googlegr oups.com... > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? > |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
It isn't 1 mm at the edge of the tire.... remember the calculations for
leverage from physics class and since the wheel is rotating we have to factor in constantly changing vectors of acceleration..... "Justin M" <xtexatl@gmail.com> wrote in message news:1163276739.067460.155360@h54g2000cwb.googlegr oups.com... > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? > |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Justin M wrote:
> OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? Hell yes. Same effect as a bent wheel, depending on where the bend is along the shaft. The closer to the hub, the worse it will be. If you hadn't gotten it apart yet, having a buddy drive alongside looking for the wobble would probably have given it away. If it's that much of a gap, you should see it if you slide the axle back in, mount a wheel and spin. |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Justin M wrote:
> OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? Hell yes. Same effect as a bent wheel, depending on where the bend is along the shaft. The closer to the hub, the worse it will be. If you hadn't gotten it apart yet, having a buddy drive alongside looking for the wobble would probably have given it away. If it's that much of a gap, you should see it if you slide the axle back in, mount a wheel and spin. |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Justin M wrote:
> OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? Hell yes. Same effect as a bent wheel, depending on where the bend is along the shaft. The closer to the hub, the worse it will be. If you hadn't gotten it apart yet, having a buddy drive alongside looking for the wobble would probably have given it away. If it's that much of a gap, you should see it if you slide the axle back in, mount a wheel and spin. |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Wow.... That's a lot of work to find a bent axle...
That should show up in the wheel if you jack it up and spin it, more than enough to vibrate. Mike 86/00 CJ7 Laredo, 33x9.5 BFG Muds, 'glass nose to tail in '00 88 Cherokee 235 BFG AT's Canadian Off Road Trips Photos: Non members can still view! Jan/06 http://www.imagestation.com/album/pi...?id=2115147590 (More Off Road album links at bottom of the view page) Justin M wrote: > > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Wow.... That's a lot of work to find a bent axle...
That should show up in the wheel if you jack it up and spin it, more than enough to vibrate. Mike 86/00 CJ7 Laredo, 33x9.5 BFG Muds, 'glass nose to tail in '00 88 Cherokee 235 BFG AT's Canadian Off Road Trips Photos: Non members can still view! Jan/06 http://www.imagestation.com/album/pi...?id=2115147590 (More Off Road album links at bottom of the view page) Justin M wrote: > > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? |
Re: TJ Vibration: rear axle bent?
Wow.... That's a lot of work to find a bent axle...
That should show up in the wheel if you jack it up and spin it, more than enough to vibrate. Mike 86/00 CJ7 Laredo, 33x9.5 BFG Muds, 'glass nose to tail in '00 88 Cherokee 235 BFG AT's Canadian Off Road Trips Photos: Non members can still view! Jan/06 http://www.imagestation.com/album/pi...?id=2115147590 (More Off Road album links at bottom of the view page) Justin M wrote: > > OK - I may have finally found the culprit. > > I pulled the rear passenger axle (the vibration always felt like it was > coming from the passenger side). First off, the bearing wasn't pushed > up against the hub like it was on the driver's side -- it has a good > 3/4" to slide back and forth on -- that would probably explain the > weird side-to-side shake I feel every now and then. > > More importantly, when I held a straight edge up to it, there is about > a 1mm bend in the center of the axle. When I hold it on the opposite > side, I have a 1mm gap at the top and bottom of the axle. > > Could a 1mm bend in the rear axle cause violent shaking? Is that big > enough to be the problem I've been hunting down for the past six months? |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:01 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands